- Shrewd Investor
- Posts
- šø #0048 - Where the Real Returns Come From
šø #0048 - Where the Real Returns Come From
How 70/20/10 helps you ignore noise and invest with intent.
ā” LIGHTNING ROUND
š 70% of short-term returns come from the marketānot your stock picks
š 20% is driven by sector trendsāfollow the flow of capital
š¢ Only 10% comes from the individual companyāfundamentals matter, but later
š Over 10+ years, that equation flips āstock selection becomes king
šÆ Use 70/20/10 to filter faster, invest smarter, and stay aligned with momentum
š¦ Stay on the Right Side of the Market
One major asset class just flipped. Another is quietly breaking out.
Inside this $4.99 report:
ā Trend signals across 12 major markets
ā Tactical ETF ideas and allocation notes
ā Updated as of August 14ābased on real momentum, not media noise
š„ Download the PDF in 30 seconds.
Put it to work in 10 minutes.
WEEKLY WISDOM
āItās easier to ride a wave than to fight the ocean.ā
FINANCIAL PLANNING HACKS
Youāre Focused on the Wrong 10% of Your Portfolio
The 70/20/10 Rule Shows Why Market and Sector Trends Matter More Than Company FundamentalsāAt Least in the Short Term
I want to show you a simple model that could change how you think about your portfolioāespecially if youāre putting a lot of time into researching stocks.
Itās called the 70/20/10 rule.
And it explains why so many āsmartā investment decisions donāt deliver the results people expectāat least not in the short term.
Where Returns Actually Come From (Short-Term)
Over a 1-year time horizon:
70% of your portfolio return is driven by the overall market (S&P, Nasdaq, macro trends).
20% comes from the sector or industry (tech, energy, healthcare, etc.).
Just 10% is based on individual company factorsālike management, valuation, or earnings.
In other words: the tide matters more than the boat.
This was backed by a 2013 paper from Edelman, Evans, and Kadlec, and itās been widely confirmed by both academic research and real-world portfolio analysis.
So if youāre putting 90% of your effort into analyzing companies, but ignoring where the market or sector is headingāyouāre misallocating energy.
Over Time, the Math Flips
Zoom out to 10 years and the picture changes:
Company fundamentals start to matter moreāa lot more.
Market direction becomes less important.
The edge comes from holding businesses that grow, manage risk well, and reinvest intelligently.
But if youāre trying to navigate 1-3 year windows? Direction matters more than detail.
How to Use This Framework
The 70/20/10 rule isnāt about picking winnersāitās about filtering your attention.
Hereās how Iād apply it:
1. Start with the Market (70%)
Is the market expanding or contracting?
Use:
Index trendlines (moving averages, market breadth)
Fed policy direction
Credit spreads and inflation signals
When markets are rising, it makes sense to stay exposed. When theyāre contracting, even good stocks underperform.
2. Narrow to Sectors (20%)
Which sectors are attracting capital?
Look at sector ETF performance (XLE, XLV, XLF, etc.)
Check relative strength vs. the S&P
Use momentum screens or fund flow data
In every bull run, certain sectors pull aheadāthink energy in 2022, AI in 2024.
3. Then Pick the Companies (10%)
Only after youāve identified strong sectors do you look at individual names.
What to filter for:
Consistent revenue and earnings growth
Strong free cash flow
High return on invested capital (ROIC)
Positive price momentum
You want names that already have the wind at their back.
Why This Helps
This approach reduces noise.
It saves you from spending time analyzing companies that are stuck in lagging sectors or swimming against a bear market.
It also helps you:
Time capital deployment more strategically
Avoid false confidence in stock picks during market downturns
Reallocate faster when leadership changes
Itās not about tradingāitās about aligning with momentum until fundamentals take over.
Actionable Next Steps
Check if your portfolio is exposed to sectors that are risingāor fading.
Evaluate if you're overweighting bottom-up analysis during a top-down market.
Start building a habit of watching where capital is flowingāthatās where outperformance usually begins.
This isnāt magic. Itās just clarity.
Markets move first. Then sectors. Then stocks.
If you get the first two right, the third becomes much easier.
P.S. š§ Got a Smart Investing Move?
Weāre collecting real strategies from readers who think a few steps ahead.
Share your best tipāand you might get featured.
š Submit Your Strategy
How do you like this sectionof this month's issue? |
The content provided in this newsletter is for informational purposes only and should not be considered as specific advice for any specific individual. The information is prepared by knowledgeable individuals and is not written by certified tax professionals or investment advisors. For personalized advice tailored to your unique financial situation, consult with a qualified tax professional, financial advisor, or attorney.
How was the newsletter? |
